Addisfortune.com

   
     
     
Search  
 

RSS

 
 
 
 
 
 
 

 News Feed

 Column Feed
 
 
 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 
 
 
 
 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

After a series of great droughts in four consecutive decades, the international aid community became wary of Ethiopia. In particular, the 2002/03 drought that exposed almost one quarter of Ethiopia’s population to famine has led to donors’ fatigue, some argue. The federal government is determined to confront food insecurity with a new strategy designed in 2005, including a productive safety net programme originally launched in four regional states, which is fully supported by donors. After billions of dollars poured into it and three years of experiment, TESFALEM WALDYES, SPECIAL TO FORTUNE, looks at the issue in depth. He discovered that the concept of “graduation” is indeed a controversial affair for those involved in the programme. 

Struggling for Graduation

Safety Net Three Years On

 

 

 

Walking barefoot, Oumar Gellete, 49, appears to be oblivious of the chilly weather that is typical to 6,063 residents of Bura Totose Kebele, an hour walk from the town of Chacha, 110Kms northeast of Addis Abeba, in the Amhara Regional State. Even at lunch time, the Angolela and Tera Wereda near Debre Brehan town could get as nippy as any place with single-digit degree centigrade temperature.
 

He ploughs any of the three scattered plots he has until dusk, without covering himself with anything warm or protective cloth; his were worn-out Chinese made pants and jacket. That is what it takes to support a family of nine, including seven of his children. Five of them go to school.
 

Life is just manageable, according to Oumar. Unlike before, when he used to harvest a single crop - barley - he now has diversified his produces, and started growing vegetables in his backyard. He recently built a house where the family sleeps, separate from where the cows and donkeys are kept.
 

“The cattle used to eat our food before we got up early in the morning,” Oumar laughed, remembering the days when the livestock shared a small hut with him and the family.


He even bought a radio set, the only symbol of affluence in the house.
 

His battle against poverty, and his marginal improvement, albeit slow, led him to be nominated as one of the “developmental heroes” from his area: These are farmers whose accomplishments are recognised by regional government authorities across the country and decorated with medals and certificates handed to them by the Prime Minister.
 

Yet, in spite of these positive developments over the past few years, Oumar still finds himself on a borderline, unable to feed his family throughout the year. He falls in the category of what development experts describe as “food insecure”.
 

His is hardly an isolated story; Oumar’s family vulnerability to poverty puts it in the list of 11,269 food insecure people found in his Woreda, which is one of the seven in North Shoa Zone, where 2.23 million people live. About 7.28pc of them are food insecure.
 

And these are people the federal government, with the help of donors it often calls development partners, wants to support in their daily struggle to overcome hunger.
 

They have developed three years ago, and are implementing, a nationwide programme, Productive Safety Net, a.k.a safety net. Oumar enrolled in this programme along with 2.5 million beneficiaries in the Amhara Regional State, a region where 30.5pc of its population is found to live under abject poverty, according to surveys conducted last year by Food Security Coordination and Disaster Prevention Office of the Regional State.
 

The introduction of safety net came in the aftermath of the 2002/03 drought, which had exposed 13.2 million Ethiopians to famine. Responding to the federal government’s appeal, donors of food aid mobilised one of the largest ever humanitarian responses.

 

Contrary to the sheer size of the population exposed to famine, hardly anyone died. They also learned a lesson that the response is only temporary. It was only a matter of time before another drought struck the nation.
 

This was a realisation that has brought a new coalition of donors to support the government in its effort and priority to ensure food security in the long term. The federal government developed a new food security strategy that comprised a resettlement programme and a household food security package aimed at helping each farmer accumulate assets. The idea was that such farmers could survive trying times without dying of hunger, whether or not drought leads to famine.
 

A five-year safety net programme was launched in 2005, with the support of eight donors, including the World Bank, the United States Agency for International Development (USAID), the British Department for International Development (DfID), and the European Commission (EC).

 

Alarmed by a growing symptom of dependency syndrome following massive international food aid since the great famine of the mid 1980s, the federal government decided to see safety net implemented in food insecure areas in a manner that involves beneficiaries doing public works in exchange for in kind or cash help.
 

At the beginning, 7.2 million beneficiaries were enrolled in four regions: South, Oromia, Tigray and Amhara regional states. The latter, where Oumar lives, accounts for 30pc of all beneficiaries registered nationwide. Lately, though, the Harari Regional State and Dire Dawa City Administration were included in the programme.
 

Beneficiaries in 276 weredas in these regions receive grain or cash after taking part in labour-intensive public works, according to Wout Soer, head of the donor coordination team of the programme. These include constructing roads, building terraces, maintaining schools, clearing ditches or developing springs, as well as conserving the environment.

 

But it is not very restrictive. Those qualifying for a set of criteria - such as old age, pregnancy or terminal diseases - are entitled to direct support. They are provided with three kilogrammes of wheat per head, daily, without being required to participate in public works.


Their number is however small compared to those doing public works in order to be eligible for support, as is the case with Kemissie town, 325Kms north of Addis Abeba; of the 411 beneficiaries in the town, only 47 are entitled to such direct support.
 

Dawa Chefa, one of the weredas in the special zone of Oromo nationalities, in the Amhara Regional State, has its offices in Kemissie town. There, 1,436 people are entitled to direct support, from the 21,420 people of the 145,000 residents that are threatened by constant food insecurity.

 

The majority of beneficiaries across the country, where Oumar belongs to, are included in the safety net programme only after involving themselves in public works. Although he too gets direct support of 810 Br for three months, owing it all to his children under 18, Oumar has taken part in public works such as environmental conservation activities, constructing a farmers’ training centre in his kebele, terracing and reforestation.

 

Farmers like Oumar get paid a daily wage of six Birr for five days of public works provided in any given month. March is in the six-month period, starting from December, allotted for such public works. This period of time is considered as a “slug period” for farmers.
 

Payment in cash takes up the bigger portion in the programme that cost donors a total of 200 million dollars, although payment in kind shares no less. Those who chose to be paid in kind receive three kilogrammes of wheat and 0.6lt of edible oil per day, calculated to be worth six Birr.

For instance, beneficiaries in Dawa Chefa Wereda are provided with 7,190qts of food aid, which represents 40pc of the programme. Such is a contribution in food aid that cost donors 150 million dollars a year, according to Mr. Soer.
 

Originally designed to expire in 2009, although that now appears to be very unlikely, the safety net programme requires an additional 600 million dollars and one million metric tonnes of food should it succeed. To their credit, both the government and donors have committed to measurable results for the programme to be called successful.

 

Each year, no less than 20pc of the beneficiaries should graduate from the programme, after accumulating enough assets in their households as benchmarked by each region and wereda. Graduation is, nonetheless, a mounting task, it was found.

 

Hardly anyone could demonstrate the uncertainty and the challenge of this process better than Oumar’s experience in life.
 

He settled at Bura Totose Kebele, coming from a nearby village located in the Oromia Regional State; he had left his family during childhood to work as a shepherd for rich farmers in the kebele.
 

When coming of age, he was conscripted to the 1978 Ethio-Somalia War, one of the 300,000 militia solders who fought for their country, only after a three-month hush-hush training. Oumar sustained a bad injury and thus discharged from the military. It was not to be his last battle.
 

Although he returned to Bura Totose, where he was granted a plot and settled as a farmer, a desperate government forced him and many of the Ethio-Somalia War veterans in the late 1980s to hold the unabated rebels at bay. Oumar was deployed on the Jerru front, 150Kms north of Addis. No sooner did the veterans arrive at the battle front, when they began to retreat; only after the EPRDF took power in May 1991 did Oumar returned back to Bura Totose.

 

Page 1 2

 
 
 
 
   
   
   
 
 
 

 

ARCHIVESABOUT FORTUNE  / FEEDBACK  
CLASSIFIED ADS / ADVERTISE CONTACT US
CONTRIBUTE  / GUEST BOOK / FORTUNE FORUM

       Home Page / Fortune News / News In Brief / Agenda / Editor's Note / Opinion / Commentary / View Point

 Cartoons / Comic Strips / Gossip

   Terms & Conditions / Privacy
© 2007 AddisFortune.com