|
It is easy to get carried away in good
times. With the impressive economic growth
of late, the impetus to be overly bullish
may be creeping into the mentality of banks.
As profits are to be reaped in a variety of
sectors, granting credit to companies of all
colours seems to be the norm for a number of
banks.
Pulling in the reigns on runaway loan
extensions may seem unnecessary in such
markets. But the signs of turning tides
usually appear after it is too late for the
majority. In seeking more of the same good
times, optimism may blind even the
traditionally prudent bankers.
Now is not the time to be overly worried,
however. Profit margins for Ethiopian banks
are some of the highest in the world. Week
after week positive annual reports are
proudly presented to shareholders with
glowing responses.
This is to be expected in an infant industry
relatively untapped according to some
measures. The ratio of bank branches to
population, around one to165,000, is still
one of the lowest in the world. This is
despite the slew of recent additions to the
industry as well as new branches for
existing institutions popping up every week.
Four new banks are in the process of
entering the market, though they will have
their own challenges to face.
These new entrants face two important
difficulties: a glaringly low level of human
resources and troubling prospects to attract
deposits.
The numerous vacancies dotting newspapers
bode well for the qualified applicants, but
speak to the trouble human resource
departments have in filling positions. Banks
find themselves competing in trying to lure
prospects away from one another. This will
inevitably lead to higher salaries and
increased overhead costs that may cut into
these profits, possibly to the point of
pushing them out of equilibrium with the
skill sets they are compensating.
The usual culprit of brain drain is in part
to blame, though recent regulations on
boards of directors from the National Bank
of Ethiopia (NBE) are also straining the
competition. A closed financial system
immune from international mega-banks will
keep this situation in place in the near
future. Nonetheless the push for World Trade
Organisation (WTO) membership could put an
end to this cosy arrangement.
Troubles attracting deposits is deeply-rooted in a largely
informal economy with low bank coverage. The
negative real interest rate is in part to
blame as well.
But despite all these challenges, banking is a good
industry to be in currently. Four
consecutive years of double-digit gross
domestic product (GDP) growth has been
fuelled in part by a booming construction
industry. Banks have been keen to fund
building and infrastructure projects.
This could lead to trouble, though, if banks are not wary
of overextending themselves. Construction
booms are notorious for leading to painful
busts. The East Asian financial crisis is a
prime example of how credit can dry up as
fast if not faster than it flooded in. The
international nature of the late 90s
catastrophe made it even worse as capital
moved out of the region completely.
While the closed account of Ethiopia is
immune to such drastic fluctuations, its
domestic system is vulnerable. Many banks
have a troubling ratio of outstanding loans
marked as long-term. Combining this with low
deposit levels could spell danger to come.
It is always difficult to make future predictions for these
financial institutions. Forecasting using
historical trends and trying to account for
recent developments tends to run into
difficulties of making overly rosy
projections in good times. Until some of
these newly constructed buildings begin
filling up with sustainable businesses, the
chickens should not be counted before they
hatch.
Recent developments involving a slew of foreclosures and
chasing after assets from big name
businesspeople seem to be isolated incidents
for now. These troubles for individuals
could start adding up and hit deeper into
the country as a whole. At the least, they
are potentially signals for deeper problems.
The regulator of state financial
institutions, which control about 50 billion
Br in assets, the State Financial
Enterprises Agency, seems the have awoken to
the potential hazards. Long considered
dormant and relatively inactive, the Agency
is co-hosting a workshop with the United
Nations Development Programme (UNDP) next
week on risk management. Inviting
international banking experts, it aims to
train executives on modern risk management
techniques.
While workshops occur all too often with little in the way
of results, this at least shows concern and
may raise awareness. With state banks
lending out about 17 billion Br, over 50pc
of total deposits, there is a lot of credit
floating around.
Bringing in international expertise is to be welcomed in
the fledgling sector liberalised shortly
after the overthrow of the Derg in the early
90s. Re-examining these portfolios in light
of new techniques or the latest in financial
analysis from industry leaders may shed some
light on how to keep the good times rolling.
The Development Bank of Ethiopia (DBE) has shown
commendable improvements in reducing their
non-performing loans (NPLs), though many
other banks have not shown as positive of
movements. Long-term credit extensions leave
the possibility of NPLs increasing unless
roaring markets persist and avoid cyclical
downturns.
One of the biggest difficulties for financial institutions
is that the real indicators of future
prospects are hidden deep beneath a pile of
figure.
Take for example Nib Bank's recent annual
report. On the surface, the shining record
profits seem to signal huge success; in part
it does. But beneath the glamour is the loan
to deposit ratio that exceeds
recommendations of the central bank. This is
not the immediate concern of shareholders,
but is rather cause for concern over the
long run.
But overall the outlook is bright for a
country with nowhere to go but up. Starting
from a low capital base, the state financial
institutions that now control 6.5 billion Br
in combined capital can continue to improve.
This is what will come of sober
consultations with experts like the one
being held this week.
The cornerstone of any risk management package is
diversification. Investing in a wide range
of industries allows risk to spread
throughout sectors that bear little in the
way of interrelated cycles. Determinants for
success in the budding flower industry are
not necessarily the same as they are for the
leather sector with huge potential.
These sectors will be leaders at present though sustained
growth will only come if the country is able
to harness its potential in an array of
fields. The banks must spur this growth
through prudent lending decisions which
allocate capital to projects with high
potential.
It will take time, though, for the banks to see
profitability in areas past the
infrastructure and building projects that
provide the foundations for later
development. If they are choosy now, the
picture for the future will be bright.
Developing this wise approach to lending will be aided if
private banks follow the State Financial
Institution Agency's lead and begin to seek
more from foreign experts in the realm of
consultations. Development agencies like
UNDP can add a helping hand too in
facilitating such knowledge-sharing.
For now, it is friendly as competition is domestic. But
once the long-term inevitability comes and
the market opens up, it is these types of
forums that will prepare the country for the
future. Then the banks can continue to play
the positive role in growth they have done
so marvellously at in recent times.
|