|
Business Process Reengineering, known in short as BPR, is a
popular expression in government circles these days.
The concept is simple: to reorganise state agencies
so that they give not only efficient but speedy
services to their clients. In the process,
transparency and accountability is hoped to become
the order of the day.
On the surface, it sounds pretty nice, but the devilish
details of its implementation have intra-agency
politics. The climax of such politicking was late
last week, staged by reformist Czars in the
government, championed by Capacity Building Minister
Tefera Walwa, and finance conservatives under the
command of Neway Gebreab, chief economic advisor to
the Prime Minister.
The sticky issue was the speed and manner of reforming the
three state-owned banks: Construction and Business
Bank (CBB), Commercial Bank of Ethiopia (CBE) and
Development Bank of Ethiopia (DBE). There seems to
be consensus on the reform platform designed by
managers of CBE, although not many of them are into
CBB yet, according to gossip. The tussle, instead,
is over the BPR plan suggested by DBE guys, as
spearheaded by Mesenbet Shenkute, vice president for
Client Relation and Branch Operation.
Those at the agency in charge of state finance companies,
an entity that has become increasingly assertive,
argue that the plan contradicts the international
risk management practice as agreed in the town of
Basel, Switzerland, following the Asian financial
crises. They want to see a Chinese Wall separate
those who appraise loan requests from the officers
approving them. They want to see what is technically
known as "segregation of duties" in loans, from
appraisals to disbursements.
The reform command centre is persuaded by DBE officers'
enthusiasm to cut the process short and fast track
the lending procedure, a desire seen by their
adversaries as a recipe for disaster for a financial
institution that is seen to be in a very precarious
situation now, according to gossip. News of the
tension reportedly reached the ears of the Prime
Minister, who advised all involved their dispute on
a roundtable.
All in fact did meet inside Tefera's office for two days
beginning Thursday; both camps were determined to
finish the other off, according to gossip. Chaired
by the reform Czar himself, there was Abay Tsehaye,
chairman of CBE, Melaku Fenta, chairman of DBE,
Neway Gebreab and their principals. Gossip claims,
Abay displayed a remarkable level of composure and
leadership while Neway was kind of quiet for much of
the time, letting his people, such as Brehane Assefa
and Yeshi Kassa do the talking.
Gossipers claim the result was not to the satisfaction of
either camp. DBE officers cannot launch their BPR
tomorrow, November 19, as they originally planned
it, and no one was fired as adversaries may have
hoped. The bigwigs have at the end agreed to form a
committee or taskforce comprising experts from the
Ministry of Capacity Building (MoCB) and the DBE to
study how many of the banks across the globe use
"segregation of duties" and how many others do not,
said gossip. It looks like a relief measure that
has, for the moment anyways, postponed the mutual
discontent.
|