Addis Fortune Home
Fortune News
News From Other Sources
Editor's Note
Opinion...
Commentary
View Point
My Perspective
Life Matters
View From Arada
Restaurant Review
Business Opportunities
Cartoons and Comic Stripes
Gossip..
Archive..


 



 

 
 
             
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 


 

It is a difficult time for minibus taxis right now. Passengers are convinced that drivers fail to provide a public service while the drivers complain that it is impossible to make a living. In an answer to the bad blood, the Federal Transport Authority has conducted a study whose findings recommend that minibus taxis follow specific routes, clearly marked on the front of vehicles, a policy that perhaps refers back to the Derg era, when minibus drivers were far more regulated. Special for Fortune, Tesfalem Waldyes, and Staff Writer, Wudineh Zenebe, took a ride into the issue.

 

Fighting the Minibus Blues

 

 

 

 

There is something about using minibus taxis in Addis Abeba these days
that makes even a city native feel like a tourist.Semneh Sissay, a marketing manager at a private company, always faces a transportation problem whenever he tries to return to his office after lunch, often at Yeshi Buna, on the Jomo Kenyatta Avenue near Bambis Supermarket.

 

On these days, he patiently stands on the sidewalk waiting for taxis for almost half an hour, while minibus after minibus passes him filled with passengers. Semneh said that he often ends up walking back to his office under the scorching sun.

 

But at around the same time that Semneh waits in vain for a minibus, just a few kilometres away from Yeshi Buna, five to seven taxis can be seen waiting for passengers taking the same route, from Stadium to Megenagna.

 

This seems the plan of action for minibus operators these days: fill up the minibus on one end of the line (like Stadium) and then rush to Megenagna ignoring passengers like Semneh, waiting in between the main pick-up and drop-off areas.

 

“They are a public service giver, said Semneh but they seem purely business minded.”

All around town this distinction is one that seems to increasingly grate. Are minibus taxis a public service - city workers who cannot always have their own bottom line in mind - or are they purely private operators, free to make their own dime driving their vehicles in whichever way they see fit?

 

Most Addis Abebans approached by Fortune are convinced that minibuses operate strictly as the latter when they should be thinking of themselves more as the former.

 

 
 

Officially, the 2005 Transport Proclamation clearly labels taxis, including minibuses, as public service givers. But the answer is not that easy. As in any other country, a commercial enterprise can also fulfil a public service goal.

 

It just seems that on the streets of Addis Abeba, this distinction is causing more and more tension between the operators and the passengers. And officialdom has begun hearing the rising complaints.

 

For starters, customers who remember the taxi system from the Derg era, remember a far more regulated time, when minibus taxis conformed to fixed prices and well assigned routes. The era felt a lot less freelance than today’s, claim passengers.

 

During the Derg, taxis were forced to fulfil specific services and routes when the government believed there was a shortage of public transportation. The 1976 Transport Proclamation, which provided the regulation of road transport, stated that the government could compel public commercial road transport vehicles, like minibus taxis, to operate in areas lacking transport services. 

 

The regime was not only forcing taxis to provide services wherever it dictated them, but also had strict control, introducing trip schedules for public transport vehicles. The Road Transport Authority was responsible for preparing and implementing trip schedules for public commercial vehicles and enforcing disciplinary directives.

 

It is with memories of this more strict time that the Addis Abeba Transport Branch Office under the Federal Transport Authority has prepared a study whose findings are similar in concept to that of the previous regime.

 

The study requests that routes be assigned and route plate names be installed on minibus taxis. The office did the study around the end of last Ethiopian fiscal year and it will be implemented after discussing the matter with the stakeholders involved in the area, in the current fiscal year of 2006-2007.

 

The essence of the study was based on complaints by commuters regarding the taxi service and driver complaints about route regulators who cause taxi owners unnecessary expenses. These self appointed route regulators are individuals or groups of people that assign routes for taxi drivers and charge them from 0.50 Br to two Birr from each minibus who leaves the taxi station. This, critics say, decreases the number of shuttles as well as the income of taxis.

 

“The daily, weekly and monthly schedule of the taxis routes will be assigned by an association to be formed,” said an official from the Branch Office. “The new arrangement will regulate the taxi service to the benefit of both the taxi owners and the commuters.”

 

As an industry stakeholder, Segon Addis Abeba Taxi Owners Association gave its inputs during the study and the Transport Development Department undertook the responsibility of overseeing it. Chairman of the Segon Association, Fisseha Mamo, is satisfied with the study.

 

“The main problem with the traffic congestion is rush hour traffic,” he said. “The assigning of routes will regulate the flow of taxi services and save taxi owners from the unnecessary expenses of route regulators.” 

 

Route regulators are not seen as the only problem. The need for regulation was exacerbated with the recent increase in fuel prices, implemented last August. Some of that cost has been passed onto the customer. The shortest ride on minibus taxis, for example, is now 65 cents, up five cents.

 

And also offsetting the rise in tariffs, which occurred alongside the fuel price adjustments, the Federal Transport Authority has given minibuses permission to add one more passenger in the back row of minibuses.

 

But even before any study gets implemented, current regulation, Fortune observed, is lacking for implementation. All across town in recent weeks, minibus taxis were seen idle for several hours during the day, usually after lunch time; work breaks that are not allowed according to regulation.

 

The reasons for the illegally idle taxis seem to vary. Taxis in Piassa, for instance, queue so as to wait for their turn to board customers while those parked in Saris are simply taking a rest until the midday heat passes.

 

In the Saris case, drivers and conductors (weyalas) usually gather together in one of the taxis, and chew Khat while discussing day-to-day incidents they encountered during work. But these types of afternoons are not exclusive to only those around Saris, as most of the city’s taxi stops display similar trend.

 

In the worst cases, some take the taxis to where they can find Khat and spend hours there. Last Thursday afternoon, there were six minibus taxis parked in front of Doro Manekia Khat sales outlets near Piassa; all drivers were in the back chewing rooms.

Tariku Abera, who has been a taxi driver for three years, spends two hours a day from 1:30pm onwards chewing Khat. The taxi that he drives covers a long route that starts from Saris Addisu Sefer to Autobus Tera via Kera. According to Tariku, he begins work at 7am and finishes at 10pm.

 

He calculates that eight shuttles cover what he has spent on fuel, the amount that will be given to the owner of the taxi and payments to the controller and self appointed route regulators, all of which cost him around 350 Br.

 

To get these expenses back, Tariku has set new working hours: he now does four shuttles during rush hours, which are most profitable.

 

“I know that my duty is serving the people but for serving the people I do not want to take a risk of losing my profit,” he said, claiming that driving a half filled vehicle outside of rush hour is not affordable anymore.

 

He admitted of only going short distances during those hours; longer shuttles are covered before lunchtime hours and after 3pm. He told Fortune that he is off the road between 1pm and 3pm.

 

Hearing of these holes in service, authorities warned staying idle for too long had serious consequences, even as far as revoking a license.

 

Tadesse Tefera, Head of Transport Development Department under the Addis Abeba Transport Branch Office of the Federal Transport Authority, wrote in a statement sent to Fortune that if public service givers failed to provide the service, the office is obligated to revoke their licenses.

 

But before the authority jumped to such decisions, the authority first takes corrective measures he wrote.  First the service givers are fined, only repeat offenders are taken off the streets.

 

Enforcement seemed far from the minds of taxi drivers who had a number of reasons why they were out of service for large chunks of the day. But Tariku said that since fuel price has escalated a great deal, a taxi driver should follow the routes assigned by the self appointed regulators. Making it up as you go along could prove to be expensive.

 

Mulgeta Tsegaye, who has worked as a taxi driver for four years, shared Tariku’s opinion. He said that previously, he took risks and picked passengers on any street in his path, but that now, after the fuel price adjustments, he chooses the assignment of routes by self appointed route regulators.  But, unlike some of his colleagues, he fears getting fined everyday. For him, the cost of a fine would sink his business.

 

And these days, even though most of them have a monthly salary of 300 Br, they do not take it for granted. Tariku complained that the strict fines for traffic offences sometimes cost him his entire salary. The lowest fine costs 40 Br while the highest reaches 140 Br. Maybe regulation then will not end up being such a bad thing.