|
The efficacy of
e-learning relies heavily on computing hardware and software; but more
importantly on the underlying network infrastructure. In the African
context, infrastructure is a necessary condition to embark upon
e-learning.
The prefix “e” in
the term e-learning figuratively represents the media that education is
transmitted into, i.e. inter-network connectivity. According to Canadian
Recommended E-learning Guidelines, the term “e-learning” is used to mean
learning using both a computer and the Internet. Among various
attributes of e-learning products or services, there are few that are of
interest in the African context: Very inexpensive or free of charge,
consistent with public education tuition; and really effective or of
superior quality.
Bandwidth
constraint within a Local Area Network (LAN) can easily be dealt with at
a nominal cost and with less technical issues. Technical issues of
content distribution within a LAN or a campus network are usually within
the technical and financial bounds of the information technology
management of the particular institution. On the other hand, content
distribution to the public, through Wide Area Network (WAN) or over the
Internet is dependent upon the available bandwidth and network services
offered by the Internet Service Provider (ISP).
We are in an era of
transmission of information in terabits per second using fiber optics,
satellite and wireless communication tools. Many African countries do
not have a resilient and robust network infrastructure that the
information revolution lives on. Access to information depends on an
uninterrupted flow of information on the super highway.
Take for instance
the available bandwidth of Kenya and Ethiopia; the limitation and
scarcity is a clear obstacle to any attempt to promote and foster
e-learning in Africa.
The Ethiopian
Telecommunications Corporation (ETC) is the sole and only telephone,
telegraph and Internet backbone provider. There appears to be no plan to
have other Internet backbone providers in the foreseeable future. Its
EthioNet Internet Services has two Satellite Internet links (both out
bound and inbound) provided by two vendors: 2Mbps 8Mbps from NSS
(Netherlands) and 4Mbps 16Mbps from Intelsat of the United States. In
total, EthioNet has 6Mbps 24Mbps.
In the context of
the general lack of backbone bandwidth for Internet connectivity, the
cost of ‘available’ bandwidth is very expensive for a pervasive
e-learning initiative for Africa. A comparison with an ISP provider in
the United Kingdom is starkly revealing.
British Telecom
(BT), a former state monopoly, supplies a router, which connects to a
computer via an Ethernet or USB port. In addition to offering
‘virtual’ unlimited calls in the UK, its business broadband connection
provides a 2mbps (40 times faster than dial-up) broadband connection, of
14.99 pounds a month (240 Br) for the first three months, and 17.99
pounds (288 Br) subsequently, with no cost to the subscriber during
set-up.
The ETC offers ADSL
on a leased line, although it said it has “introduced a new type of
Internet Service coined as ‘Shared DSL’, which could fall in between the
Leased Line and Dial-Up Internet services”. It charges 905 Br per month
for a not-so-bad 256Kbps connection service. The cost of a 2mbps
broadband connection from the ETC, a state monopoly, is 41,479 Br a
month without including the set-up cost of 103,406 Br Although these are
two different societies with wide gap in their developments, this
comparison between Ethiopia and the United Kingdom helps to draw an
objective picture of affordability and availability of Internet
connectivity for e-learning for poor African countries.
The alternative for
affordable delivery of e-learning is the use of other content delivery
media such as CD-ROMs and broadcast TV. Notwithstanding the viability of
e-learning with other content delivery mechanisms, the Internet is the
medium of choice and the main transport mechanism for all forms of
e-contents. Whether it video, audio or text data, the Internet has
become the de-facto media and transport mode.
The Internet has
changed everything. It provides the pleasures that CD-ROM could only
dream of, like physical and material interaction between learners and
tutors. Nobody wants to burn stacks of CD-ROMS and bother with the
logistics of shipping and handling. Nobody seems to want to make
learning applications that ran as executable files on CD-ROMs or from
hard drives; everyone wants content delivery through an Internet
browser.
Moreover,
e-learning content providers output their data in the form of massive
files in various proprietary formats. One cannot expect every computer
to be pre-loaded with all sorts of plug-ins and add-ons. Such updates
are assumed to be downloaded from a vendor’s website. Nevertheless, most
of these downloads are huge files that require a significant bandwidth.
Thus, without adequate bandwidth, e-learning results in an odious user
experience.
Thus the concept of
e-learning without any consideration of an affordable as well as a
robust, reliable and redundant network infrastructure would be
unimaginable. Since the choice of delivery of content is via Internet
browsers, with severe bandwidth difficulties in the African continent,
e-learning becomes a nightmare.
Even if one can
afford expensive African network connectivity cost, the bandwidth
constraint would surrender to undesirable e-learning user experience.
|