|
Last Monday, January 25, 2010, in the early
morning hours, an unexpected and devastating
thing occurred on the Mediterranean Sea a
few kilometres off the coast of Beirut, the
capital of Lebanon. At approximately five
minutes after taking off from Beirut’s Rafik
Hariri International Airport for a flight to
Addis Abeba, the passengers and crew members
of Flight Number ET409 became aware of an
inevitable crash.
All communication from the air traffic
control room at the Beirut International
Airport was cut off, the outcome being the
unavoidable plane crash.
As the third plane crash in the 63 year
history of the airline, this may go down in
records as one with no survivors. This has
thrown the air transport system into chaos
and the government into crisis causing the
Ethiopian populace, including the country’s
leaders, to fall into national mourning and
remorse.
People connected with commercial aviation
or, for that matter, anyone at all cannot
simply watch what happened to the Ethiopian
Airlines Boeing 737-800 accident without
feeling a strong sense of dismay and
despondency.
In a nutshell, regardless of the wide
economic and political divide, the world
reaches out to a grief-stricken nation.
This incident is particularly distressing
given that Ethiopian enjoys the reputation
of rendering excellent flight services
dating back for more than half a century as
one of aviation’s pioneers in the African
continent.
One important point, though, is that the
airline should not tear apart its
management, staff or operating procedures
over what appears to be a tragic accident .
This is an accident and it could happen to
any airline anywhere in the world. The fact
of the matter is accidents have little to do
with the capacity of the airline.
But this whole unpleasant incident revealed
some thwarting actions taken by government
officials on both the Ethiopian side and the
Lebanese side.
The accusations, finger pointing and search
for a culprit to blame among the officials
of the two governments a couple of days
following the accident echoes a lack of
response when is comes to crisis management.
It reveals that depressingly little has
changed on how authority figures on both
sides respond to aviation accidents, despite
the harm done to the nation’s aviation image
and reputation following that.
Officials seem to be playing the impractical
blame game and the subsequent search for
villains.
Oh, come on! That should not even be on the
menu as a last option, especially in a
situation like this.
At least, if the blame game is unavoidable,
it would be decorous to wait for the
retrieval and release of the cockpit tape
i.e. Black Box of the Ethiopian Airlines
crew’s final deplorable seconds then move to
censure anyone such as the air traffic
controllers on duty at the time.
One thing that ought to be mentioned is that
the pilot was qualified for the flight or
any flight for that matter. He obtained his
pilot’s licence in 1987 and had accumulated
numerous flying hours.
Searching for the facts, the whole facts,
and nothing but the facts should be the task
at hand.
Officials owe, at least, this to the victims
and their anguished family and friends since
they deserve to know the truth. And the
truth is the only thing that can clarify the
mist that has been covering the whole
situation.
Moreover, Captain Habtamu Benti had the
legacy of always taking extra care and then
subsequently declining to land a plane and
cancelling a flight en route if necessary.
It is highly doubtful that managing a crisis
situation like this will create a “just
culture” within the airlines, as it already
exists.
On the contrary, Ethiopian Airlines, with
its deferential Chief Executive Officer
(CEO) Girma Wake and all staff members,
deserves a mighty and heartfelt standing
ovation. They have managed to handle the
mayhem in an organised way from suitably
propagating information, to setting up a
toll-free hotline, to handling the victims’
families in a dignified manner.
But beyond the patriotic support and applaud
for Ethiopian Airlines, this is an opportune
moment to do some soul searching.
Ethiopian Airlines is currently working on a
lot of expansion projects like acquiring
more planes, constructing a four star hotel,
expanding cargo facilities, and expanding
networks flight routes.
International efficiency and safety awards
have been issued. However, the devil is in
the details, meaning that the airline should
not push one of its most valuable assets,
its crew members, to their limits,
especially if complaints are coming from the
crew members themselves.
One thing worth mentioning is the condition
of crew members fed up with overloaded,
strained working conditions and distanced
management. An unforeseen work-to-rule
slowdown and the system’s inability to
handle strong crew member demand is bound to
find its way to a headline. It would be more
upsetting for the continent’s most
successful airline to go into the red this
year.
The International Airline Transport
Association (IATA) is going to scrutinise
the airline on these and other technical
issues.
Being scrutinised could be a blessing in
disguise, allowing Ethiopian Airlines to
make some modifications on the work process
of the organisation.
Yet it is just as possible that the
airline’s leaders are recognising that
things cannot go on as they have.
They should do what has to be done and spend
what has to be spent to make air travel safe
and efficient as well as address the needs
of the cabin crew.
Perhaps that should include reducing the
flight hours from 120 hours per month to 90
hours per month or maybe it should not.
So far, not enough is known about the causes
of the 737-800 crash to make that
recommendation.
But unless the authority is insulated from
the political process, adequately funded,
and empowered to speak out on safety issues
without fear of repercussions, it is
difficult to see what will be accomplished
by such a move.
Regardless of who operates the airports and
airway systems, it is vital that all
stakeholders work together to address safety
challenges. That includes airlines,
airports, the air navigation services
provider, government safety regulators and
the airplane manufacturing community.
One thing is certain, however. And this is
should not be taken as one of those useless
tips or empty remarks.
Before Ethiopian Airlines recovers from this
setback to get back to business as usual,
like composing beguiling maxims such as
“Going to Great Lengths to Please” or
“Africa’s Link to the World,” or to leaping
into yet another success oriented endeavour,
the airline should reorganise and correct
some of the drawbacks of the past.
And that can actually be one way of
honouring the memory of the Mediterranean
Sea accident victims. |